Free Web Hosting Provider - Web Hosting - E-commerce - High Speed Internet - Free Web Page
Search the Web

Doubleclick Opt-Out

compiled by Lady Nastasiia Ivanova Medvedeva

How about the myth that SCA singers can't wear corsets because it will impede their breathing so they won't be able to breath? I'd like to have that myth pounded into the ground. Every time I make a properly fitted corset for one of my acquaintances that sing in the SCA I have to overcome this "Oh, I can't wear anything so constricting because then I can't sing!" Never mind that the costumes they chose make them look dowdy without their bosoms being supported (much less their pear shaped tones!

Regina Romsey


And...of course...pink isn't period....

Jessamyn


It's amazing how widespread the same myths are.
Here in An Tir I heard:
Buckles aren't period.
Buttons aren't period.
Buttons are period, but not functional, only decorative *ROTFLMA* why bother??
Pink isn't period.
No machine sewing should show ( I tend to follow this from personal preference not because it was a rule).
Poofy pants are period in Germany.
Surnames aren't period.
Celts are Irish. Period. then...
Knotwork is Irish.
Violins aren't period. Okay, maybe they weren't *exactly* violins, but explain the under the chin, 4 stringed instrument in Fashion in the Age of the Black Prince and tell they aren't reasonable facsimiles.
Chunky Amber and other stone necklaces are were worn by everyone in SCA period because they didn't make fancy jewelry.

Merouda


Jonica Hogan wrote:
I still don't understand this one but someone told me that "all garb should be sewn so that no stiches are showing" Maybe it is just me because I learned to sew on my own but how can you?

Cynthia du Pré Argent replied: Maybe they meant "no machine stitching showing?" That would make more sense. I've seen some garb recently that made liberal use of wide satin stitch at the edges -- screamed modern to me more than tennis shoes do, since it was around the neck, where you couldn't avoid seeing it.

Since you mentioned buttons, my second favorite myth is "they didn't have buckles -- they used these large rings for belt fastenings."


And what about the other side of the coin, the myths about things "someone" says you *can* wear, which are not quite right:
And those leather belts with the metal ring in them, which I've never seen anywhere outside an SCA event. :)

Drea


OK how about the "myth" that you can't go out of your encampment at Pennsic unless your garb is ENTIRELY hand-sewn.
OR
At your first SCA event you wear a big blue feather to announce that you are a "newby"
OR
At your first event you have to know & understand EVERY SINGLE RULE (written and un-) !!!!
Thankfully I only had to deal with the last one, and I told that person that if that was the way the SCA was played then what were they doing here!! I thought the perfectionists convention was down the road.

Katheryne


OR how about the one:

You can't wear a circlet in the Kingdom of Aethelmaerc unless you are a "Lady". And if it is metal you have had your AoA for over a year!

(ROYAL RASPBERRY!!!!)

Katheryne


Always be suspicious of the "rules" that begin with "They never" and "They always". Other than obvious modernities like Indiglo wristwatches and shiny Lycra-nylon, etc, "always" and "never" don't really apply. A sumptuary law from Florence wouldn't have meant squat in Venice, a fashion in London might have been laughed out of Cordoba, and there would have been a few nonconformists then as now - the difference being that the "penalties" might have been a bit harsher ("Wearing your brother's trousers again, Joan? Okay, that's it, off to the stake.....") And the passage of sumptuary laws everywhere were a pretty good indication that folks were breaking them and would continue to do so....

Liadain


And of course let us not forget the "Only Royals Can Wear Purple" with which so many newcomers have been intimidated......

Liadain


Got to put my two cents in.

Corsets don't stop you from singing. They also don't stop me from playing sacbutt (trombone) in my tightly laced late Italian corset. And, as all low brass players know, t-bone takes a heck of a lot of wind.

Elizabeth Young


I have heard:
"They" never lined anything in satin.
All period skirts were lined.
Pink isn't period.
Pastels aren't period.
Elizabethan corsets were made of iron.
Buttons were invented in the 17th century (Louis XIV)--on NPR, shame on them, they shoulda known better.
My favorite--All blackwork is supposed to be reversible.
--Maire


If you have any other clothing myths you'd like to add, please write to Tasha.